Trinidad Alcoa Pollution

Trinidad Gas Price TT$3 per litre   -   Venezuela TT$1 per GALLON!
Trinidad Car Licensing Fee avg. TT$20,000   -   United States TT$200 (per year)
Trinidad Sales Tax (VAT) 15%    -   United States Sales Tax - 4%
Trinidad Oil Wealth? Not for you and me!

 

The financial truth behind the Alcoa Deal (what they don't want you to know!)

Electricity

Did you ever wonder why T and Tec is talking about raising rates at the same time as the Alcoa Deal is being pushed? The real truth is that Alcoa is promised an huge amount of electricity at A DISCOUNT. In short, Trinidadians will be asked to pay more for their electricity while Alcoa gets a bargain out of tax payers expense.

Natural Gas

The smelter plants are powered by Natural Gas. Great, more money for our energy reserves? Actually, NO!!!
The government promised Alcoa a discount on our energy (gas,oil whatever it may be) as well. While the whole world is willing to pay us the going rate for our gas and oil, Alcoa gets it at a discounted price. Who has to pay for this discount? The tax payers...you!

Water

How many tanks do you have stacked up in your backyard just to be able to take a shower in the morning? Is that normal? Do you think anybody in any country where there are smelter plants has such a flaky and defective water supply that they need tanks? How much worse will things get when Alcoa comes in and not only consumes large amounts of water but also pollutes the meager rest that's left over for us.

Housing

It has already been made clear that the government is planning the same thing in Chatham and the Cedros Peninsula they done in Union Village. Take people's land and offer them to live in NHA ghettos (some crime plan!) Our constitution guarantees us that we can live where and how we want. The government is using compulsory aquisition like a free for all shopping spree. That is NOT the intention of the law. There has to be a clear need, no alternative and a BENEFIT for Trinidians before you should take somebody's land. As you can see from the facts above, there is NO BENEFIT for Trinidadians.

In addition, we are now talking about housing 1,400 Foreign Construction Workers for the Alutrint Smelter and 1,000 permanent Chinese workers to operate the Union Village Alutrint Smelter. Meet your new Chinese neighbour:  Sum-Guy-Tief-Yu-Job and family.

Economy


In Brazil, the Alcoa smelter in Sao Paolo costs the Brazilian tax payers 120 million US$ annually on subsidies.

In the Victoria Province of Australia, three smelters provided 1,600 jobs and cost the tax payers $110 million annually, that is $70,000 per worker.

In Australia, the cost of 'doing business with Alcoa' is passed on to the general public by higher electricity rates. Sounds familiar?

No feasibility study has been done for the Alutrint smelter. The smallest parlour going to get a loan has to show a business plan with projected income, competitors, planned buyers. Alutrint plans to spend hundreds of millions of taxpayers dollars and has no plan.  Should we not be doing a Feasabilty Study as an Article of the National Environment Policy states for energy sector commitments?

More Trinidad facts.....

"Trinidad and Tobago, the leading Caribbean producer of oil and gas, has earned a reputation as an excellent investment site for international businesses. Tourism is a growing sector, although not proportionately as important as in many other Caribbean islands. The economy benefits from low inflation and a growing trade surplus. Prospects for growth in 2004 are good as prices for oil, petrochemicals, and liquified natural gas are expected to remain high, and foreign direct investment continues to grow to support expanded capacity in the energy sector. The government is coping with a rise in violent crime." Source CIA Factbook

Except for the crime situation Trinidad sounds an excellent place for investment for Alcoa. However the questions remains why is Trinidad interested in an industry that will have to be subsidized and therefore detrimental to the balance sheet of  T & T.  Yes, subsidized, because electricity is such an important ingredient of an aluminum smelter (God knows what will happen if the power goes out for a few hours) and for the plant to be financially viable, the government will be building an electrical plant for Alcoa and then charging them below market rates for electricity for the plant to be profitable. Also for Alcoa the natural gas prices would be lowered for it to be worthwhile for Alcoa to operate. Does this make economic sense? Why will we go into an industry where we have to sell our Natural Gas at prices below what we can get on the open market, there isn't exactly a shortage of demand for natural gas. The government will be going through all these hoops to establish a joint venture in which they are the minority shareholder, this is not making sense.

Look at Trinidad's statistics:

GDP: -purchasing power parity - $11.48 billion (2004 est.) 

GDP: - per capita: purchasing power parity - $10,500 (2004 est.)

Population below poverty line: 21% (1992 est.)

Labour force - by occupation: agriculture 9.5%, manufacturing, mining, and quarrying 14%, construction and utilities 12.4%, services 64.1% (1997 est.)

Unemployment rate: 10.4% (2004 est.)

Oil - production: 140,000 bbl/day (2004 est.) At today's current oil price of $60. US per barrel, that is sales of over $8 million US per day in oil alone. Yet this revenue increase hasn't filtered down to the population. Supplying the population's basics needs has not improved, food prices are up, housing costs have increased and health care is still awful. One goes to an emergency room at a major hospital and has to sit in pain for hours before seeing a doctor.

Highways: total: 8,320 km  paved: 4,252 km  unpaved: 4,068 km (1999 est.) All the money and our roads are still in disrepair.

definition: age 15 and over can read and write
total population: 98.6%
male: 99.1%
female: 98% (2003 est.)

With this high rate of literacy why in the world is the government soliciting menial jobs? What about free computer training to make the youths ready for information age jobs and not go backwards to the industrial age.

With the billions of dollars that come from the coastline of the south-west, is it unreasonable to have an ambulance in the peninsula or does a child with the possibility of a fractured spine have to wait 3 hours for an ambulance to come from San Fernando? Is it unreasonable for the Icacos children to want a proper school? Alcoa is promising a community centre to Cap-de-ville residents, but who would want to stay in a community with smoke, dust, unhealthy emissions and the potential for diseases.

 

| Home Page | Latest News | What can I Do?|  Articles | Useful Links |  Discussion Board |